about icon-addNote android4 Answer apple4 icon-appStoreEN icon-appStoreES icon-appStorePT icon-appStoreRU Imported Layers Copy 7 icon-arrow-spined icon-ask icon-attention icon-bubble-blue icon-bubble-red ButtonError ButtonLoader ButtonOk icon-cake icon-camera icon-card-add icon-card-calendar icon-card-remove icon-card-sort chrome-extension-ru chrome-extension-es-mx chrome-extension-pt-br chrome-extension-ru comment comment icon-cop-cut icon-cop-star Cross Dislike icon-editPen icon-entrance icon-errorBig facebook flag flag_vector icon-globe icon-googlePlayEN icon-googlePlayRU icon-greyLoader icon-cake Heart 4EB021E9-B441-4209-A542-9E882D3252DE Created with sketchtool. Info Kebab icon-lamp icon-lampBig icon-learnHat icon-learning-hat Dislike Loup Loup icon-more icon-note icon-notifications icon-pen Pencil icon-play icon-plus-light icon-plus icon-rosie-cut Rune scrollUp Share-icon Shevron-Down Shevron Left Shevron Right sound sound1 sound2 sound3 sound4 sound2 icon-star Swap icon-translate Trash icon-tutor-ellipsis icon-tutor-flip Tutor folder icon icon-tutor-learned icon-twoWayArrow Mezhdunarodny_logotip_VK vk icon-word pen_icon Logo Logo Logo
Go to Questions & Answers
Tatiana Tanyaasked for translation hace 8 años
How to translate? (ru-en)

он сказал, что сделал успехи в английском

User translations (1)

  1. 1.

    He said he's made progress in English.

    translation added by ⁌ ULY ⁍
    Gold ru-en
    3

Discussion (18)

Aleh Laadded a comment hace 8 años

to Uly: why "he's made" and not "had made"?

⁌ ULY ⁍added a comment hace 8 años

If I'm not mistaken, the Russian could be interpreted as a present eventuality or a past, no?

Aleh Laadded a comment hace 8 años

I'm not sure if I got your question right, but we have the action in past "сделал", and we have indirect speech. So, binding them both together we get to the past perfect tense, no?

⁌ ULY ⁍added a comment hace 8 años

What I meant is that the original Russian sentence can be interpreted in two ways depending on the situation: (this morning) He told me he's made progress in English. -or- (last year, after his trip to New York) He told me he had made progress in English. Is that right?

Aleh Laadded a comment hace 8 años

If I wanted to say that progress in English was done "this morning", I would specify it with something like "за сегодняшнее утро." Otherwise, I would assume that the progress was made during some time preceding TODAY or NOW. But! Shouldn't the past perfect be used in indirect speech regardless when it happened, as long as it happened before someone said about it?

⁌ ULY ⁍added a comment hace 8 años

¿Are both of these correct: (1) Сегодня утром мы с Андреем завтракали вместе. Я спросил у него, как проходят занятия по английскому и он сказал, что сделал успехи в английском и теперь понимает больше. (2) В прошлом году Андрей работал шесть месяцев в Англии. Я заметил, что он очень свободно говорит и он сказал, что сделал успехи в английском.

⁌ ULY ⁍added a comment hace 8 años

In English they would be: (1) This morning I had breakfast with Andy. I asked him how his English classes are going and he told me he's made progress in English. (2) Last year, Andy worked in England for six months. I noticed that he was speaking very fast and he told me he'd made progress in English.

Aleh Laadded a comment hace 8 años

Basically, they are both correct. I should've mentioned before, that the words "сделал успехи " sound unnatural to begin with, as if some of the Russian -Brooklynites said it. )) In both of your examples I would use "добился успехов". It sounds much better.

I'm confused about your sentence(1) in English. From what I know, the way to go from direct speech to indirect is as follow:
He said, - "I've made progress in English." - He said he'd made progress in English"
I just went through my Azar's English Grammar. Not a single example of use of present perfect in indirect speech.

⁌ ULY ⁍added a comment hace 8 años

The fact is that if what you're reporting is still true and valid in the present, then you can use a present tense. In this case, we're talking about progress, which refers to a gradual movement towards success. If you report about someone's status at any point during that movement, you can use the present. For instance, say there's a nazi hunter looking for a specific war criminal. In one interview he "tells the reporter that he's made progress in finding..." This is possible because the search is still ongoing. It's still valid and true in the present. http://usatoday30.usatoday.com/news/topstories/2008-07-17-720533519_x.htm

⁌ ULY ⁍added a comment hace 8 años

In this example, your man has made progress in English and is going to continue to study and make more progress: "I asked him how his English classes are going and he told me HE'S MADE PROGRESS in English."

⁌ ULY ⁍added a comment hace 8 años

I hope this makes sense. If not, ask me and I'll give you more examples.

Aleh Laadded a comment hace 8 años

It does make sense. Thank you! Just one more thing. Would it be correct to use past perfect in the same situation without any change in meaning? Would both of them "..said Thursday he'S made progress in.." and "..said Thursday he'D made progress in.." have the same meaning? Or, the use of "he'S" in this particular situation is still preferable for the reason you explained above?

⁌ ULY ⁍added a comment hace 8 años

Yes, you can say: On Thursday, Aleh told me he's made progress in English" because it doesn't matter when you said it - it's valid NOW.

⁌ ULY ⁍added a comment hace 8 años

Here's an interesting article. Look at the very bottom and it will tell you when you don't need to change tenses in reported speech.

Aleh Laadded a comment hace 8 años

Thanks again!

Tatiana Gerasimenkoadded a comment hace 8 años

It s like one more discovery here. Nothing of the kind in the coursebooks. Thank you, Uly.

⁌ ULY ⁍added a comment hace 8 años

My pleasure, Tatiana :)

Share with friends