about icon-addNote android4 Answer apple4 icon-appStoreEN icon-appStoreES icon-appStorePT icon-appStoreRU Imported Layers Copy 7 icon-arrow-spined icon-ask icon-attention icon-bubble-blue icon-bubble-red ButtonError ButtonLoader ButtonOk icon-cake icon-camera icon-card-add icon-card-calendar icon-card-remove icon-card-sort chrome-extension-ru chrome-extension-es-mx chrome-extension-pt-br chrome-extension-ru comment comment icon-cop-cut icon-cop-star Cross Dislike icon-editPen icon-entrance icon-errorBig facebook flag flag_vector icon-globe icon-googlePlayEN icon-googlePlayRU icon-greyLoader icon-cake Heart 4EB021E9-B441-4209-A542-9E882D3252DE Created with sketchtool. Info Kebab icon-lamp icon-lampBig icon-learnHat icon-learning-hat Dislike Loup Loup icon-more icon-note icon-notifications icon-pen Pencil icon-play icon-plus-light icon-plus icon-rosie-cut Rune scrollUp Share-icon Shevron-Down Shevron Left Shevron Right sound sound1 sound2 sound3 sound4 sound2 icon-star Swap icon-translate Trash icon-tutor-ellipsis icon-tutor-flip Tutor folder icon icon-tutor-learned icon-twoWayArrow Mezhdunarodny_logotip_VK vk icon-word pen_icon Logo Logo Logo
Go to Questions & Answers

Ангела 🌙added a note 2 anos atrás

note (en-en)

When "who" can't be replaced by "that"?

For example, it is Sheila who/that is planting flowers.

But in one case who can't be replaced. When?

1

Discussion (8)

Electric Rainadded a comment 2 anos atrás

We can't replace "who" with "that" when we speak about details we can neglect. In that part of a sentence, we should use "who". This part is called a non-defining relative clause. It's separated by commas:
It was Sheila, who was planting flowers.
We use "that" in a defining relative clause; it is not separated by commas. We use defining RC when we mention important details. For instance:
Sheila has a beautiful garden that she waters every weekend. It's easy to remember: if there are no commas, we can use "that". If there are, there's no more place for "that", we can't use it anymore.
This topic is called Relative Clauses. This topic is rather essential, so I'd recommend thoroughly studying it :)

⁌ ULY ⁍added a comment 2 anos atrás

Incorrect! It was Sheila who was planting flowers. [no comma]

⁌ ULY ⁍added a comment 2 anos atrás

Correct: The detective spoke to Sheila, who was planting flowers at the time. [comma]

⁌ ULY ⁍added a comment 2 anos atrás

Angela, there's nobody on this site to help you with English. Don't learn English from Russians or any other non-native nationality. There are too many native English speakers in the world to waste your time here.

Ангела 🌙added a comment 2 anos atrás

Uly, can you advise any native speaker to practice with ? I can help with Russian in my turn

⁌ ULY ⁍added a comment 2 anos atrás

Do you have Telegram?

Share with friends